Well, it's time for the first real post in this blog. Here goes...
Rant Alert
Following the agenda which was set by the webcomic reviewer John Solomon almost a year ago, I recently read Shortpacked! by David Willis.
Going into the comic, I had nothing to go on other than Solomon's opinions on the comic. For those of you who have not read Solomon's Shortpacked! article, I suggest that you do so now, because it's the best review he's put out to date. For those of you who don't care to read it, the gist is that Shortpacked! used to be funny before Willis began putting a bunch of drama into his strips.
Unfortunately, Solomon may have exagerated just a little bit. I went into the comic expecting a Megatokyo-caliber shift of writing style. It never happened. For the most part, the strip retains the same style of jokes from its start to the present time. What made Solomon so upset?
Okay, so I lied earlier. The strip does change, although you could consider it a beneficial change. Prior to this strip, Shortpacked! was more or less a collection of joke strips. You probably could have read them in random order and not missed much. When one of the characters pulls the drama tag (literally), we now have Drama.
What do we think of when we hear the word "Drama"? Solomon maintains that although the definition of Drama (according to www.thesaurus.com) is comedy, "drama is pretty much the unfunniest thing you can have in a webcomic. It is the antithesis of comedy" Unfortunately, the esteemed Mr. Solomon seems to be confusing a few other definitions. Solomon uses "comedy" and "funny" synonymously, and that's fine. In our present day society, that's pretty much the way everybody thinks. Go back to Shakespearean times or to the ancient Greeks, and you only have two kinds of stories. A "Tragedy" is any story in which the main character is dead, dying, captured, tortured, hideously maimed, married to his mother, etc at the end of the story. A "Comedy" is any story that isn't a Tragedy. Says nothing about the story having to be funny, although that is a good way to get readers.
But you know what? Drama can be good too. What Shortpacked! gains is not "Drama" so much as it gains a continuity. We can now have story arcs that build off of prior arcs. The jokes are still there for the most part, but our characters now have depth, even if it's only a little bit.
The problem with Drama is that it means that things have to change. The comic is no longer about a bunch of people who work in a toy store. Now, the comic is about a bunch of people, and right now they work in a comic store. Tomorrow they might get fired, or become a US representative, or anyhting else.
Is it possible to have drama in a story and still keep it at a point where everybody likes it? Questionable Content has drama, but for the most part things return to what is more or less status quo within a few weeks. Megatokyo has drama and things change from day to day (roughly one year if you live in the real world). Personally, I like my stories to have at least a little drama. It keeps the characters a little more three-dimensional and dynamic, it gives the story continuity...the only comic I really read that is completely free of drama is xkcd.
The Rant is over, Time for an actual Review
Artwork:8/10 The artwork is clean, keeps a consistant style, and allows for the characters to be easily distinguished from each other. One could probably accuse Willis of not working to improve at all, but his current artwork is still way above average.
Story: 6/10 The comic lacks a well defined story, but the premise of the comic is not one that requires much of a story, nor is it expected for there to be much of a story. Occasional attempts at Drama could be viewed as unsuccesful attempts to create a story, and detract from the jokes.
Characters: 8/10 The characters are well defined and moderately complex. Some minor characters may not be as "real"
Appeal:9/10 The appeal in Shortpacked! would be the jokes, mainly. They mostly revolve around toys, usually targeted so that people in the 20-30 year old age group will have the best understanding. Drama adds depth to the characters but does not provide much additional appeal. Sometimes jokes may seem to be redundant and use the same material over and over again.
Overall Score: 8/10
